Interview Questions for an Interviewer

What are Interview Questions for an Interviewer?

Interview questions for an interviewer are designed to evaluate the candidate’s ability to conduct effective, fair, and professional interviews. These questions explore their understanding of recruitment best practices, ability to assess candidates accurately, and strategies to provide a positive candidate experience. These questions also assess the interviewer’s problem-solving skills, communication style, and approach to ensuring unbiased and inclusive hiring decisions.

What is your experience conducting interviews?

When to Ask: At the beginning of the interview, to understand their background.

Why Ask: To gauge their experience and familiarity with conducting interviews.

How to Ask: Use an open-ended tone to encourage them to provide details about their experience.

Proposed Answer 1

I have over five years of experience conducting interviews for both technical and non-technical roles, focusing on structured and competency-based approaches.

Proposed Answer 2

I’ve led over 200 interviews for positions ranging from entry-level to managerial roles, emphasizing clear evaluation metrics.

Proposed Answer 3

My experience includes managing one-on-one interviews, panel interviews, and collaborative hiring processes across diverse industries.

How do you prepare for an interview with a candidate?

When to Ask: Early in the interview, explore their preparation process.

Why Ask: To assess their ability to plan and gather relevant information before an interview.

How to Ask: Ask the candidate to describe their step-by-step preparation process.

Proposed Answer 1

I review the candidate’s resume, job description, and hiring goals, and I prepare a list of questions tailored to the role.

Proposed Answer 2

I collaborate with the hiring team to ensure alignment on what we’re looking for and structure the interview accordingly.

Proposed Answer 3

I familiarize myself with the candidate’s background, prepare technical or situational questions, and ensure the interview panel has a consistent evaluation framework.

How do you evaluate a candidate’s cultural fit?

When to Ask: During the discussion of their interview strategy.

Why Ask: To understand how they assess candidates beyond technical skills.

How to Ask: Frame the question to allow them to share examples of how they evaluate fit.

Proposed Answer 1

I use behavioral questions to assess how candidates have approached teamwork and conflict in the past.

Proposed Answer 2

I ask scenario-based questions about workplace challenges to see if their values align with the company’s culture.

Proposed Answer 3

I evaluate their communication style and adaptability, and I include team members in later interview stages for their input.

How do you handle situations where a candidate is uncooperative or difficult?

When to Ask: To explore their problem-solving skills and professionalism.

Why Ask: To determine how they maintain composure and control during challenging interviews.

How to Ask: A specific example of how they’ve managed such a situation.

Proposed Answer 1

I stay calm and attempt to re-engage the candidate by asking open-ended questions or clarifying any misunderstandings.

Proposed Answer 2

I politely address their concerns and refocus the conversation on the role and expectations.

Proposed Answer 3

If the candidate remains uncooperative, I conclude the interview professionally and document the incident for the team.

How do you ensure fairness and eliminate bias during interviews?

When to Ask: Midway through the discussion, assess their commitment to ethical hiring.

Why Ask: To ensure they understand and implement practices to promote diversity and inclusion.

How to Ask: Invite them to describe their approach to creating a fair and unbiased interview process.

Proposed Answer 1

I use structured interviews with consistent questions for all candidates to reduce bias.

Proposed Answer 2

I rely on collaborative evaluation, where multiple interviewers provide feedback to ensure fairness.

Proposed Answer 3

I avoid assumptions by focusing solely on skills and examples provided, and I consciously check my own biases during decision-making.

How do you measure the success of your interviews?

When to Ask: Toward the end of the interview, evaluate their results-driven approach.

Why Ask: To understand how they assess the effectiveness of their interviewing process.

How to Ask: Encourage them to describe any metrics or outcomes they use.

Proposed Answer 1

I measure success by tracking offer acceptance rates and long-term retention of the hires I’ve selected.

Proposed Answer 2

Candidate feedback about the interview process is a key indicator of success.

Proposed Answer 3

I consider success when the hire proves to meet or exceed expectations in the role.

How do you develop interview questions for a specific role?

When to Ask: When discussing their planning process, early in the interview.

Why Ask: How they tailor their questions to match job requirements.

How to Ask: Ask them about their process for creating role-specific questions.

Proposed Answer 1

I study the job description, identify key skills and qualifications, and design behavioral and technical questions accordingly.

Proposed Answer 2

I collaborate with the hiring manager to understand role-specific expectations and develop questions to assess those competencies.

Proposed Answer 3

I review similar roles we’ve hired for, use candidate personas, and research trends to prepare comprehensive questions.

How do you assess a candidate’s problem-solving skills during an interview?

When to Ask: During the discussion about their evaluation techniques.

Why Ask: To explore their ability to assess cognitive and analytical abilities.

How to Ask: Request specific examples of techniques or questions they use to evaluate problem-solving.

Proposed Answer 1

I use scenario-based questions where candidates need to explain how they would solve a specific problem.

Proposed Answer 2

I ask candidates about real-life challenges they’ve faced and how they overcame them.

Proposed Answer 3

I evaluate their responses to hypothetical problems during case studies or simulations.

How do you handle candidates who provide incomplete answers?

When to Ask: When discussing how they manage challenges in interviews.

Why Ask: To determine how they probe further and encourage candidates to elaborate.

How to Ask: Ask for an example of how they’ve approached this in the past.

Proposed Answer 1

I ask follow-up questions to clarify or expand on their initial response.

Proposed Answer 2

I give them a moment to think and rephrase the question to help them provide more detail.

Proposed Answer 3

If needed, I guide the conversation by providing examples or prompts for them to elaborate on.

How do you handle situations where multiple candidates are equally qualified?

When to Ask: Toward the middle of the interview to assess decision-making skills.

Why Ask: To evaluate their ability to differentiate between candidates and make fair decisions.

How to Ask: Frame the question as a hypothetical scenario and ask for their strategy.

Proposed Answer 1

I focus on cultural fit and how each candidate’s unique skills align with team needs.

Proposed Answer 2

I consult with the hiring team and review additional factors like communication style and long-term potential.

Proposed Answer 3

I may conduct a second round of interviews to explore their skills or perspectives more deeply.

How do you provide feedback to unsuccessful candidates?

When to Ask: Toward the end of the interview, when discussing the candidate's experience.

Why Ask: To understand their communication skills and commitment to maintaining a positive hiring experience.

How to Ask: Ask them to describe their tactful approach to delivering feedback.

Proposed Answer 1

I provide constructive feedback by focusing on specific areas for improvement while remaining encouraging.

Proposed Answer 2

I keep the feedback professional, concise, and based on evaluation criteria to ensure clarity.

Proposed Answer 3

I thank the candidate for their time and emphasize areas of strength before discussing growth opportunities.

How do you avoid unconscious bias in interviews?

When to Ask: During discussions on ethical hiring practices.

Why Ask: To evaluate their awareness of bias and commitment to fostering diversity and inclusion.

How to Ask: Ask them to share specific practices or tools they use to eliminate bias.

Proposed Answer 1

I use structured interviews with standardized questions for all candidates.

Proposed Answer 2

I focus on evaluating answers based on objective criteria rather than personal impressions.

Proposed Answer 3

I participate in training to identify and mitigate unconscious biases in the hiring process.

How do you handle tight deadlines when hiring for multiple roles?

When to Ask: When exploring their ability to prioritize and manage workload.

Why Ask: To assess time management and organizational skills.

How to Ask: Present this as a situational question to see how they strategize.

Proposed Answer 1

I prioritize roles based on business needs and delegate tasks when possible.

Proposed Answer 2

I streamline the process by pre-screening candidates and focusing on key qualifications.

Proposed Answer 3

I communicate transparently with the hiring team and adjust expectations to meet deadlines effectively.

How do you ensure a positive candidate experience during interviews?

When to Ask: Midway through the interview to understand their focus on candidate experience.

Why Ask: To evaluate their communication style and ability to create a welcoming environment.

How to Ask: Invite them to share their strategies for making interviews a positive experience.

Proposed Answer 1

I create a friendly atmosphere by introducing myself and explaining the process clearly.

Proposed Answer 2

I ensure interviews are structured but flexible enough to accommodate candidates’ needs.

Proposed Answer 3

I provide timely updates and feedback to keep candidates informed throughout the process.

How do you collaborate with the hiring team to make final decisions?

When to Ask: Toward the end of the interview to assess teamwork skills.

Why Ask: To determine how they balance individual input with team collaboration.

How to Ask: Ask for examples of how they’ve worked with others to make hiring decisions.

Proposed Answer 1

I lead discussions to gather feedback from all interviewers and summarize key takeaways for consensus.

Proposed Answer 2

I ensure that all perspectives are considered by facilitating open communication and objective evaluations.

Proposed Answer 3

I organize post-interview debriefs to align on the best candidate based on agreed-upon criteria.

How do you adapt your interview approach for remote candidates?

When to Ask: When exploring their flexibility and technical adaptability.

Why Ask: To evaluate their ability to conduct compelling virtual interviews.

How to Ask: Ask for examples of how they’ve successfully interviewed remote candidates.

Proposed Answer 1

I ensure a smooth virtual experience by testing technology and communicating expectations beforehand.

Proposed Answer 2

I focus on building rapport virtually by maintaining eye contact and using engaging body language.

Proposed Answer 3

I adapt my questions to account for remote work challenges and ensure candidates feel comfortable.

How do you stay updated on best practices in interviewing and recruitment?

When to Ask: During the discussion about their professional development.

Why Ask: To assess their commitment to continuously improving their interviewing skills.

How to Ask: Ask them to share specific steps or resources they use.

Proposed Answer 1

I attend workshops, webinars, and HR conferences to stay informed about the latest hiring trends.

Proposed Answer 2

I regularly read industry blogs, articles, and research papers on recruitment strategies.

Proposed Answer 3

I participate in professional networks and communities to exchange ideas and learn from peers.

What steps do you take to evaluate both technical and soft skills during an interview?

When to Ask: When discussing their methods for assessing candidates comprehensively.

Why Ask: To ensure they have a balanced approach to evaluating technical expertise and interpersonal qualities.

How to Ask: Encourage them to provide examples of questions or techniques they use.

Proposed Answer 1

I use technical tests or problem-solving exercises for hard skills and behavioral questions for soft skills.

Proposed Answer 2

I evaluate technical skills through role-specific scenarios and soft skills through team-based problem discussions.

Proposed Answer 3

I look for examples from their past experiences demonstrating technical expertise and collaboration.

How do you structure an interview to ensure it stays on track?

When to Ask: When discussing time management and planning.

Why Ask: To assess their ability to run efficient and organized interviews.

How to Ask: Ask them to describe how they plan and manage the flow of an interview.

Proposed Answer 1

I prepare an agenda with time allocations for introductions, questions, and closing remarks.

Proposed Answer 2

I stick to a structured list of questions but remain flexible if deeper probing is required.

Proposed Answer 3

I use clear guidelines for each interview stage to ensure everything is covered within the allotted time.

How do you handle situations where a candidate asks unexpected or challenging questions?

When to Ask: To evaluate their ability to handle surprises professionally.

Why Ask: To gauge their adaptability and composure during interviews.

How to Ask: Present this as a hypothetical scenario and ask for their approach.

Proposed Answer 1

I respond honestly, and if I don’t know the answer, I promise to follow up after the interview.

Proposed Answer 2

I see it as an opportunity to learn about the candidate’s perspective and clarify their concerns.

Proposed Answer 3

I remain calm, acknowledge the question, and provide as much information as possible within the scope of my knowledge.

How do you ensure compliance with legal and ethical standards during interviews?

When to Ask: When discussing their understanding of hiring regulations.

Why Ask: To assess their knowledge of laws and ethical practices in recruitment.

How to Ask: Ask for examples of steps they take to comply with legal and ethical standards.

Proposed Answer 1

I avoid asking personal or discriminatory questions and follow a consistent process for all candidates.

Proposed Answer 2

I stay informed about legal requirements, such as equal employment opportunity laws, to ensure compliance.

Proposed Answer 3

I rely on structured evaluations and focus only on job-relevant criteria during interviews.

How do you manage situations where there is disagreement among the hiring team about a candidate?

When to Ask: To explore their conflict resolution and teamwork skills.

Why Ask: To assess their ability to mediate and drive decisions collaboratively.

How to Ask: Ask them to share examples or describe their approach to resolving such conflicts.

Proposed Answer 1

I encourage open discussion and ensure all viewpoints are heard before making a decision.

Proposed Answer 2

I facilitate consensus by aligning the discussion with the job requirements and evaluation criteria.

Proposed Answer 3

I propose a re-evaluation or additional interviews if the team remains divided.

How do you handle a situation where a candidate is overqualified for the role?

When to Ask: When assessing their judgment and communication skills.

Why Ask: To understand how they manage overqualified candidates while ensuring a positive experience.

How to Ask: Frame it as a scenario-based question to explore their approach.

Proposed Answer 1

I focus on understanding their motivations and clarify how the role aligns with their goals.

Proposed Answer 2

I discuss potential growth opportunities within the company to gauge their long-term interest.

Proposed Answer 3

If appropriate, I communicate concerns openly and provide honest feedback about fit.

How do you handle situations where a candidate’s references provide conflicting feedback?

When to Ask: When discussing post-interview evaluations.

Why Ask: To assess their ability to interpret and resolve discrepancies in feedback.

How to Ask: Present it as a hypothetical situation and ask for their decision-making process.

Proposed Answer 1

I contact additional references to gather more context and clarify the discrepancies.

Proposed Answer 2

I assess the feedback alongside interview performance and other evaluations to form a balanced view.

Proposed Answer 3

I address conflicting feedback directly with the candidate, if necessary, to gain clarity.

How do you handle confidential information about candidates during the hiring process?

When to Ask: Toward the end of the interview, evaluate their professionalism and integrity.

Why Ask: Ensure they understand the importance of responsibly handling sensitive information.

How to Ask: Ask for specific practices they follow to protect confidentiality.

Proposed Answer 1

I ensure all candidate information is stored securely and shared only with relevant stakeholders.

Proposed Answer 2

I adhere to strict confidentiality policies and avoid discussing candidates outside the hiring team.

Proposed Answer 3

I use encrypted systems to manage data and ensure compliance with data protection regulations.

For Interviewers

Dos

  • Research the candidate’s background and tailor questions to the role.
  • Maintain a professional yet conversational tone to create a comfortable atmosphere.
  • Take notes and actively listen to responses to ensure accurate evaluation.
  • Use open-ended and behavioral questions to understand the candidate’s experience and skills.

Don'ts

  • Avoid asking leading or discriminatory questions.
  • Don’t interrupt the candidate or rush their responses.
  • Avoid relying solely on first impressions or intuition.
  • Don’t neglect to clarify or probe further if a response seems incomplete.

For Interviewees

Dos

  • Prepare detailed examples of past work and relevant skills.
  • Be clear, concise, and honest in your responses.
  • Maintain eye contact and professional body language.
  • Ask thoughtful questions to demonstrate an interest in the role and organization.

Don'ts

  • Avoid giving overly rehearsed answers.
  • Don’t provide vague or unrelated responses to questions.
  • Avoid speaking negatively about past employers or teams.
  • Refrain from asking questions solely about salary and benefits upfront.

What are Interview Questions for an Interviewer?

Interview questions for an interviewer are designed to evaluate the candidate’s ability to conduct effective, fair, and professional interviews. These questions explore their understanding of recruitment best practices, ability to assess candidates accurately, and strategies to provide a positive candidate experience. These questions also assess the interviewer’s problem-solving skills, communication style, and approach to ensuring unbiased and inclusive hiring decisions.

Who can use Interview Questions for an Interviewer

These questions are beneficial for:

  • Recruiters: To evaluate candidates applying for recruitment and interviewer roles.
  • HR Teams: To ensure team members have the right skills to conduct interviews.
  • Hiring Managers: To select qualified professionals to assess potential hires.
  • Aspiring Interviewers: To prepare for roles involving hiring and evaluation processes.

Conclusion

These 25 questions provide a comprehensive way to evaluate a candidate’s ability to excel as an interviewer. By focusing on their experience, preparation, fairness, and professionalism, you can ensure they are equipped to contribute effectively to the hiring process. This structured approach helps assess their strengths, identify potential challenges, and select candidates aligning with your organization’s values and goals.

Ready to interview applicants?

Select the perfect interview for your needs from our expansive library of over 6,000 interview templates. Each interview features a range of thoughtful questions designed to gather valuable insights from applicants.

Build Your Own Interview Agent